We’re open and ready to welcome you! Stay informed on the latest National Park Service updates here.

The Mystery of Mummy Joe: Cody Yellowstone’s Oldest Resident

Posted by: Park Country Travel Council
Posted on: October 25, 2025

Some legends are spooky. Others are simply legendary. As the nights grow longer, a different kind of mystery rises in Cody Yellowstone—one preserved not by magic, but by high-plains history.

While most autumn stories fade with the season, one local legend has remained preserved for over a thousand years, literally. Hidden high in a volcanic cliff near Wapiti Valley lies one of the oldest mysteries in the American West: the story of “Mummy Joe”.

 

Wapiti Valley in the fall
Mummy Cave is hidden in plain site along Buffalo Bill Scenic Byway in Wapiti Valley.

Who Was Mummy Joe?

In the early 1960s, local resident Gene Smith stumbled across what he thought was a cave tucked north of the Shoshone River. Turns out, it wasn’t a true cave — more of a deep overhang carved into volcanic rock. But definitions didn’t matter much once archaeologists uncovered what lay inside.

There, high in the cliffs above Wapiti Valley, they found the naturally mummified remains of a man who had died nearly 1,200 years ago. Cody locals gave him a name: Mummy Joe.

A Perfect Place For Preservation

Mummy Joe hadn’t been embalmed or prepared in any ritual way. Instead, he was laid to rest beneath a rock cairn inside what’s now known as Mummy Cave, more than 6,000 feet above sea level. The dry air and cool temps of the high-elevation cliff created the perfect environment for preservation.

What they found around him told an even bigger story.

What We Know About Mummy Joe (and what we don’t)

While there’s a lot we’ll never know about Mummy Joe, experts have pieced together a lot about his life. Here’s what we know for sure:

  • Mummy Joe was undoubtedly an accomplished big game hunter. His final resting place was surrounded by thousands of animal bones — bighorn sheep, deer, and other large game.

  • The site had been occupied for over 8,000 years, from around 7280 B.C. to 1580 A.D., making it one of the longest continuously used archaeological sites in North America.

  • His people were skilled survivalists. Archaeologists found perishable tools like arrows with intact feathers, woven baskets, nets, and beads — all surprisingly well-preserved.

  • Many artifacts predated Joe by centuries, with some basketry and bone tools dating back over 5,000 years. These items gave researchers a rare look into Native American life in the Rocky Mountain West.

  • Mummy Joe was once on display, but that changed in 1990 with the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA). His remains — along with sacred objects — were respectfully returned to affiliated tribes for reburial.

A Cave That Still Speaks

Old Town Trail sign with an image of Bob Edgar on it.
Bob Edgar was one of the first people to excavate and seriously study Mummy Cave.

One of the first to study the site seriously was Bob Edgar, a Cody-based archaeologist, conservationist, and founder of Old Trail Town. He saw the cave not just as a trove of artifacts, but as a time capsule, echoing with the voices of generations who had lived, hunted, and died in those cliffs.

Today, Mummy Cave remains one of the most important archaeological sites in Wyoming, and one of the most mysterious. You won’t find flashy signs or paved parking lots. Just a quiet trail, a windswept cliff, and a story that refuses to fade.

Old buggies and cabins in Old Town Trail
Bob Edgar also founded Old Trail Town/Museum of the West, which is celebrating its 50th anniversary this year.

Want to Find Mummy Joe’s Hideout?

You won’t need a fedora or a bullwhip — just curiosity, good boots, and a respect for the land. The Mummy Cave site is tucked along the North Fork Highway near Wapiti, and while the interior is protected, the wild views alone are worth the stop.

Saddle up and explore the mystery. Hike the valley. And while you’re here, uncover more untold stories in Cody Yellowstone. Request your Vacation Guide and start planning your journey through 10,000 years of high-plains history.

Travel Guide - Background

Get Your Free Cody Yellowstone Vacation Guide

Start planning your wild adventure with the help of our free guide.